In all my years of reviewing albums ( 15, yes! it’s true) I always come across a small quandary: shall I review a record in the context of the previous releases or as an individual record. Here I will attempt both.
In the context of the discography: Courtney Barnett has had a strong run. Here first two EPs showed potential. Her debut album, Sometimes I sit and think and sometimes I just sit was AMAZING. It’s in my top 10 albums of all time. Great lyrics, great hooks even the sequencing was flawless. Then to top it off, last year’s collaboration with Kurt Vile , Lotta Sea Lice was another great move.
Which leads us to her second album proper, Tell Me How you Really Feel which is… a bit of a let down to be honest. It’s not that it is a bad album but compared to her debut it’s a bit normal. For starters, with exception of a couple lines here and there, the clever wordiness of the past is gone. The music itself is good but it sounds a bit like a grunge knock off at times ( I will admit there are some new instruments in the mix). In fact Kelly and Kim Deal of The Breeders sing backing vocals on standout track Crippling Self-Doubt and a General Lack of Confidence, thus both past and present are entwined. I can’t help thinking that Barnett’s previous releases were better though.
As an individual album: If one takes each track individually, the yes this is a good album. Each song is catchy, has a good chorus and is definitely a more energetic and slightly noisier record, even angrier in places. Also each of these tracks can be a single so I won’t be surprised if I see more videos in the future. Like her previous albums, Tell Me… is sequenced beautifully and that is something I like.
Total Summary: Tell Me How you Really Feel is a good solid album that will attract a lot of fans but in the grand scheme of things Barnett has displayed better lyrics and riffs in the past but this is not a record to discard as it shows Barnett taking a more streamlined path, which a lot may like but I prefer the quirkiness of the past.